Transgender Methodist pastor re-appointed
A transgender man will remain as pastor of a United Methodist Church in Maryland, the church’s highest judicial entity ruled Tuesday.
According to The Baltimore Sun, the Judicial Council ruled that Rev. Drew Phoenix, formerly Rev. Ann Gordon, would be re-appointed to St. John’s United Methodist Church. The decision reaffirms Bishop John R. Schol’s decision last spring.
The Sun reports:
Schol’s action had been appealed to the Judicial Council by several local clergy in the Baltimore-Washington Conference, who have raised questions about the proper role of transgender people within the church.
Tuesday’s ruling concluded that “a clergyperson’s good standing cannot be terminated without administrative or judicial action having occurred and all fair process being accorded.”
The Methodists’ Book of Discipline bars noncelibate gays and lesbians from serving as clergy but does not include any commentary about transgender people. In addition, Tuesday’s decision by the nine-member council, made up of laypeople and clergy, did not specifically address “whether gender change is a chargeable offense or violates minimum standards” of United Methodism.


